When it comes to great pizza, sometimes the best flavors are the ones you never saw coming. At Alley Cat Pizzeria in Manchester, NH, we’re all about pushing past the ordinary and creating pizzas that surprise, satisfy, and keep you coming back for more. Whether you’re a longtime local or discovering us for the first time with Manchester delivery, these unexpected pizza pairings might just become your new favorites.

Sweet, Spicy, and Seriously Addictive: The Wild Cat

If you think pineapple only belongs on a debate panel, not pizza, The Wild Cat is here to change your mind. This bold combination of jalapeños, crispy chicken tenders, and pineapple delivers the perfect balance of heat, crunch, and sweetness. The jalapeños bring the spice, the chicken adds hearty texture, and the pineapple cuts through it all with a bright, juicy finish. It’s a high-energy slice that proves opposites really do attract.

Italian Deli Meets Pizza Night: The Calico Cat

For fans of classic Italian flavors, The Calico Cat is a must-try. Fresh slices of mortadella, salami, and capicola are layered generously over melted cheese, then topped with a zesty hot relish that adds just the right kick. This pizza delivers rich, savory depth with a spicy edge, making it perfect for anyone who loves bold, traditional flavors—just served in a totally unexpected way.

Creamy, Garlicky and All Things Comfort

For something a little more mellow—but still full of personality—this pairing delivers serious comfort. Roasted garlic and caramelized onions create a deep, savory base, while creamy ricotta adds richness to every bite. Finished with a garlic butter drizzle straight from the Alley Cat menu, this pizza is smooth, aromatic, and perfect for anyone who loves classic flavors with a twist. What is this creation of awesomeness you ask? Well, it’s the White Cat, of course!

Bold and Tangy: Bacon, Onions, and BBQ Drizzle

This combo is made for flavor seekers. Smoky bacon provides salty richness, while pickled red onions add crunch and tang. Finished with mozzarella and a light barbecue drizzle, this pizza hits all the right notes—savory, sharp, and just a touch sweet. It’s bold without being overpowering and always a crowd-pleaser. If you’d prefer chicken over bacon, check out the Fat Cat; a house favorite!

Pizza That Breaks the Rules | Alley Cat Pizzeria

At Alley Cat Pizzeria, we believe pizza should be exciting. These creative pairings are designed to surprise your taste buds and elevate your pizza night. Whether you’re dining in or ordering Manchester delivery, our menu proves that stepping outside your comfort zone can be delicious.

Next time you’re craving pizza in Manchester, skip the predictable and try something unexpected. With convenient Manchester delivery and flavors you won’t find anywhere else, Alley Cat Pizzeria is ready to redefine your idea of the perfect slice. Do you have a unique flavor combination? Head over to our Facebook page and share!